Reality Nation » Big Brother » Best BB Player Bracket: Dan vs. Jeff

Best BB Player Bracket: Dan vs. Jeff

Who was the better Big Brother player?

Dan Gheesling (@DanGheesling): Big Brother 10
1. Winner of BB10 with a unanimous 7-0 vote
2. Member of The Renegades Alliance. Replacement Nominee Roulette Anyone?
3. Three HOH wins and two Veto wins

Jeff Schroeder (@JeffSchroeder23): Big Brother 11, 13
1. Part of the Veterens alliance in BB13, loyal to Jordan Lloyd both seasons
2. Combined, won a total of 4 POVs. BB11 2 times (Weeks 2 & 7) & BB13 2 times (Weeks 5 & 7)
3. Won America’s choice season 11 receiving $25,000.00

Vote for today’s female houseguests!

Not sure what the Big Brother bracket is about? Learn more about it here.

Comments

http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa

It’ll be interesting to see how the ladies justify their vote for Jeff, let the cat fur fly!
- http://twitter.com/MizJones602 Michelle Jones
  
  They all want to ‘do’ him and their lust blocks sound judgment…
  - guest1
    
    you caught us that has to be it because obviously noone but you could have sound judgement…
    - http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa
      
      Then explain yourself.
      - guest1
        
        I dont have to explain myself to you or anyone else ..this is a poll based on opinion and ultimatley the winner doesnt mean shit you all look down on jeff and jordan fans but you people are the worst.You constantly degrade the fans and think you know all. vote your way i will vote mine and leave it at that..clearly you need a job or a hobby or something
      - http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa
        
        “I don’t have to explain myself to you or anyone else!!”
        - Idiot
- guest1
  
  The ‘cat ladies”bit is really getting old give it a rest…noone gives a shit. noone has to “justify” their vote to anyone you can place your vote wherever you want it to go…never underestimate the power of jeff and jordan fans!!
  - http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa
    
    This line you folks use about not having to “justify” your vote to anyone is an excuse to cast your vote emotionally and recklessly, which violates the spirit of this competition. I would be okay with this cat lady rampage if you just came right out and admitted that you’re voting for JeJo because you love them and you want to see them win everything. But when you lie and pretend that you have a factual basis for your vote and then thrown up some paper-thin nonsense argument that makes no sense, it becomes pathetic.
    
    Back to the kennel with you!
    - guest1
      
      what are you voting for president or something..its a silly poll we can vote anyway we want to vote..your pathetic get a life
      - http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1017520006 Adam Alamillo
        
        You’re*
      - http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa
        
        A woman living vicariously through two people semi-famous who will never know her name or acknowledge her existence is calling someone pathetic… LOL!
        
        A-CHOO! Sorry, my allergies are acting up.
      - guest1
        
        go back to all 5 of your followers im sure they love you…get a grip on reality buddy your obviously obsessed with this i feel sorry for you
      - http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa
        
        You’re desperate honey, what non-celeb/public figure cares about their # of twitter followers?
        
        I’m an opinionated fan of a widely successful and long running reality series; you’re a keyboard jockey with a strange fixation on a pair of thirty-something reality stars. Perhaps you should re-think who is more deserving of your pity.
      - guest
        
        Since when is 26 thirty something. LOL You don’t even have a clue what your talking about.
      - http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa
        
        Congratulations, you just proved how oddly transfixed you are on a pair of strangers.
        
        I’ll wear your comment about not having a clue about JeJo’s personal lives as a badge of honor.
      - guest1
        
        i have a strange fixation on reality stars? really because i choose to vote the way i do..you are the one having the meltdown its sounds like your the one with a problem and no my pity is well placed you have it for sure. Its going to be okay really it will the outcome of this vote will not change the world..take your medication and go to bed i dont want that split personality of yours getting out of hand..chill out please
      - http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa
        
        Lol remind me who’s having the meltdown again?
        
        You have a strange fixation because you took a poll based on competitive skill and warped it into a popularity contest where you cast your vote based on how enamored (read: obsessed) you are by a television personality. All your comments are so surface-level that you’re either a very high functioning retard or a middle school dropout.
        
        Please go.
      - guest1
        
        im neither one thankyou…and by the way referencing someone as a “retard” is very offensive…how do you know how i base my vote? give it up and fixate on something that is meaningful maybe you could devote your time working with kids with disabilites as i have a niece with disabilities and i find it very offensive that you reference that be thankful for what you have in life instead of putting those less fortunate down. Grow up and act like an adult thats assuming you are one
      - http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa
        
        Boo hoo, everyone has their own set of problems in life. Deal with them with dignity instead of shoving them in everyone’s face and spare me your indignation. That’s the adult thing to do.
        
        Begone.
      - guest1
        
        why dont you make your posts about voting for who you want to vote for instead of making it a personal attack. you started this because you dont agree with my vote then so be it dont agree i dont care..this vote is over and it is clear who the winner was..look the world is still standing .
        imagine that .im not shoving anything in anyone’s face when you start calling people retards i do take it as a personal attack .and yes the world is full of problems so try focusing on that instead of your obsession with me. grow up
      - http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa
        
        Obsessed with you? Sweetie this conversation should have ended yesterday, stop hounding me for attention.
      - Hhhhfhfhfufh
        
        Hypocritical much? You are telling someone to do something productive yet here you are behind your computer doing what? I find your grammar and spelling horrendous, and this is coming from a 13 year old boy. I’m just tired of jejo fans who refuse to use logic. Do something productive and go die in a hole to make the world a better place. -Tapbutt from roblox
      - http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa
        
        It’s*
Patworx

Dan is our last hope!
Billyw

wow, there is no way to beat the jeff & jordan lovers… i like them both but there is NO WAY jeff was better then Dan!!!.. Dan in my opinion was the best player EVERRRR!~
gma

Just as many vote against Jeff and Jordan just so they won’t win, many vote for them just to piss you people off. Jeff and Jordan lovers (I do like them, but not a fanatic, like many) are no worse than Jeff and Jordan haters. Sit back and take a look at yourselves.
- Corndogger
  
  Actually a lot of us are voting based on who we thought was the better player and justify our votes. What Dan accomplished in BB10 is way beyond what Jeff did in either BB11 or BB13.
  - guest
    
    Bullshit your delusional if you don’t think people vote against them just because they are Jeff and Jordan.
    - Corndogger
      
      Pay attention. I said “a lot of us” not “everyone.” I actually like Jeff and Jordan but I’m a realist and I know they did not play the greatest games. Dan played a great game over coming many obstacles and he won 7-0 which has never been done before. I’m voting on game play and in that department Dan > Jeff.
      - guest1
        
        your entitled to your opinion corndogger for sure im not saying that..i would just like to chime in here and say lets be real just because you got a 7-0 vote does not mean you were the best game player ever more then likley it means the other person sitting beside you sucked even worse then you did
      - Faceones
        
        guest once again hiding under a assume nic we all know neither jj should be in finals
      - Www Knowsless
        
        obviously not everyone because they won…suck it up and get over it
      - Www Knowsless
        
        obviously not everyone because they won…suck it up and get over it
Coloradoangel1978

I love Jeff and he is one of my fave hg’s ever but let’s be honest here. Dan was in a pickle the entire season he was on and go out of it to win by a vote of 7-0. I had to throw my vote to Dan on this one.
http://twitter.com/TonyVolpe78 Volpe

poor Dan, more cat food
Faceones

dan had no chance and what is wrong with cats? not all his fans has them btw
Olive

OMG can’t wait to see what happens when the final is Jeff vs. Jordan. Will the cat ladies be torn between the two or will they just keep voting for Jeff, since they want him all for themselves….
- guest1
  
  stay tuned! MEOW!
Aiden

C’mon…. If we are going by best strategies and game play it’s Dan hands down….
sepen

WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE, AND FUCK YOU WHOEVER PUT THIS POLL TOGETHER AND INCLUDED JORDUMB AND THE HOMOPHOBE
http://twitter.com/therocprince Cory

Is this the final bracket?
http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000175635622 Andrew Sloan

Final 2 should be Dick and Dr. Will!! Dan gets my vote because he was smart with his bold moves. Jeff was not.
maymay

If Jeff wins against Dan, I will have lost all hope for humanity.
Elizabeth

Unfortunate that people have to respond with hate and slanderous commentary on what is ultimately a meaningless poll. Hoping the RN moderators will act on that accordingly. Vote for who you feel should win and move along.
2scoops

I thought we were voting for best BB player? So why is Jeff winning right now!
Kalimnafisi

Will is by Far the best Male Player. He won his original season, then came 4th on All stars, and he would have won if Janelle hadnt Evicted him. Dan played Amazing in BB10, so he deserves to be here, but What did Jeff do. Get 5th and 7th, playing a poor strategic game. This voting is clearly based on favorites and no Best Big brother PLAYER
- http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1017520006 Adam Alamillo
  
  I think Dan could even be bigger than Will in the future. Let’s just see how All Stars 2 turns out.
  - http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa
    
    It’s possible, the fact that he’s more accessible to the fans could push him over edge. It all depends on his performance on All-Stars though.
    - Dholman09
      
      I agree with everyone about Dan i think if he appears on the next All stars he could definitely turn out to be a better plan than Will but for know, personally, i think Dr.Will is still the top dog but Dan is SUPER close!
Sandra

HUGE JJ fan but I voted Dan. Jeff could’ve made it further both times if not for a little more smarts in the final 5 POV BB11, Jordan winning that FF HOH that Kalia won or having a little more luck in the clownshoe POV but Dan did win at crunch time so he gets my vote. I don’t care what people think about who I am a fan of but I can vote objectively. Jeff/Jordan will always win these types of polls because they have the biggest fan base out there so get over it.
jmb510

Meow…I voted for Jeff even though I think Dan is a better player. I just like to mess with the people who seem to take these silly polls so damn seriously. “If Jeff wins, I will have lost all hope for humanity”? And the cat ladies are the crazy ones?
kungfuwomn

Hey why not vote Jeff for Gov of California i am sure Jeff would win that race too ,they need to change the name of thsi contest to the most popular not the best player contest.Jeff didnt even make it to Final 3 in any of his seasons? I dont think Jordan should have beat Janelle but Jordan at least won her season and was 4th in BB14,beating Jeff in both seasons. So really this contest should really not be taken seriously.
Sid

Two Words….Clown Shoe

BAHHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAA
Kyraben

I don’t even remember Dan.
- Corndogger
  
  Did you not watch BB10?
http://twitter.com/bronsonsherrie sherriebronson

Jeff was a major player in 2 seasons and was playing with another person with whom he was totally loyal while needing to make decisions that effected them both. Their combination of competition wins, social wins, and support of America has contributed to one of their duo getting farther in BB history than all but one other person ever. Jeff won America’s player both of his seasons while accomplishing this. Their support and efforts had a lot to do with the winner of BB 13. This duo competed with character and concern for others, a result of that is they have a huge group of people who support them. Many reasons support their being the best players. The community of voters interested in BB will determine the winner. All can vote and have a say in the results.
- artharsh
  
  LoL no the donato tag team>jejo tag team jeff is s sore loser and a bully end of story.
http://www.facebook.com/people/Tom-Palmer/898110719 Tom Palmer

being a catlady has nothing to do with having cats.
http://twitter.com/bronsonsherrie sherriebronson

I haven’t seen this mentioned–to me about the best speech of BB history was Jeff’s motivational talk to the other vets right after ED had to leave. It IMO had a MAJOR effect in the vets’ actions going forward which was a definite turning point in season 13. I believe Dani saw that she could control Brendon and Rachel much better than Jeff and Jordan.
- Corndogger
  
  If Jeff’s speech had just an impact on the other vets then why did Allison have to have Dick come on the next week and talk to them to get their spirits up?
  - guest1
    
    yes because Dick’s speech was so emotional it had me sitting on the edge of my seat..lol be real. He came on because he left so quickly and he had to explain why and because his daughter was still in the house he had to make some sort of statement it wasnt to ‘rally” the troops that was for sure
    - Corndogger
      
      You sure love to revise the facts. Dick was asked by the producers to come on to do exactly what I said. You make it sound like he decided on his own to takeover a segment of a live show. And he never explained why he left because if he did people wouldn’t still be wondering what the reason was.
      - guest1
        
        who gives a shit what the reason he left was…noone he sure the hell gave no pep talk thats for sure…You act like everyone was so down on the game and wanted to leave the house and the last resort was having dick come on to magically make people want to go on…get real. go fixate on something else
      - Corndogger
        
        Looks like a struck a nerve. Also looks like you didn’t watch the feeds last year.
      - guest1
        
        no nerve struck here…you live in your own reality and thats fine..move on honey its gonna be okay dont fixate im sure if you call dick he can give you one of those famous ‘lifting spirits’ speeches..relax make yourself a corn dog and get some sleep..tomorrow is a new day
BangBang

All you people that adore Jeff are insane. He was a LOUSY player. Just because you ladies drool over him does not make him a good player. He is racist, sexist, homophobic douchebag. This poll is not FAVORITE BB player, it is BEST BB player.
- Top2ruffyouup
  
  Have to totally agree here. This is not about misplaced idolatry, this is “supposed” to be about skill (for lack of a better word) in the Big Brother game. The only really smart move that Jeff made in either of his season was his use of his Coup de’ tat… and hell we gave that to him. I would have liked the final two to have been some combination of Dan S10, Will S2/all stars, and Danielle S3/all stars.
- http://www.facebook.com/people/Thenton-Burke/100001174383618 Thenton Burke
  
  Jeff is a racist? Sounds like you are the racist. I bet you call italians all sorts of racist names behind closed doors.
  - BangBang
    
    A) Epic logic fail moron
    B) I’m Italian… Please note the word Italian should be capitalized.
    C) I did not see you defending against him being sexist or homophobic, am I to infer you agree with me on those points.
Will

I’m so sick of the cat ladies ruining the legitimacy of these polls. They need to look past whatever they see in JeJo and recognize some actually good players.
PureEvel

As a STAUNCH Jeff/Jordan fan, I can say that I voted honestly and it was for Dan (although he is at the top of my list of favorite players as well). See, not all old cat ladies vote for Jeff blindly (although I don’t own a cat, lol).
TruthTeller

What a stupid poll. All true big brother fans know that Dan played a smarter, stronger & better game then Jeff did. The end.
- http://www.facebook.com/people/Thenton-Burke/100001174383618 Thenton Burke
  
  Never! Big Jeff for the win!!! Huzzah!!!
Doodoodoowgas

So these polls are officially a joke now right?
Paula

The Dream Crushers of Reality Nation silly, silly polls! LMAO! Never underestimate the power of a kitty!
- guest1
  
  careful now cats spray dont get too close we might piss on u
Faceones

anyone who thinks that jeff should be here is goofy best player not most popular and jj and br are my all time favorites and i will not vote that way
http://www.facebook.com/people/Thenton-Burke/100001174383618 Thenton Burke

Big Jeff for the win!!! All day, every day!!! Huzzah!!!
Dholman09

Ok sure Big Jeff has a loyalty to Jordan- duh! Thats his girlfriend in season 13. But the way he handled situations with Kalia and how he always criticized her just made him look like a bully to me. I think the only bullying that was actually okay was evel dick because Jen didnt have it together those first weeks and Dick had to antagonize those to get people to turn on one another and get him further in the game. All big Jeff did was talk season 13, i admit i liked him during his first season because he was the underdog but last season he was totally different. Sure Jeff won some HOHs so did Dan. I believe Dan was the better player because even though he may have got on peoples bad sides he did it in the name of the game and wasnt as annoying as Jeff in season 13. Dan had a great strategy- lay low then stir things up and he won vetos as well. His alliance actually made it to the end and he was loyal to Memphis. But the biggest thing to look at is the facts, Dan beat Memphis 7-0 and won the game because Dan actually focused on the game and not who slept all day. I’m sorry i’m just keeping it real, i mean i was a fan of Jeff the first season he was on but i think he was still to bitter about him losing his past season. This comment isn’t to anyone in specific and I dont mean to offend anybody this is just my opinion and i understand Jeff fans have their own as well But anyways, im super excited for july 12 and it better be All- Stars 2! Hey maybe even Jeff and Dan may be on it… who knows lol!
Cperio

Dan should have won this poll. He won his season. He played the best game. Jeff was on for two seasons and isn’t win 1. Too me Dan in my all-time favorite BB player and winner:)
Jlynn

I love Jeff, but you have to answer honestly not by how much you like someone. Dan WON Jeff didn’t. CASE CLOSED! How could Jeff be a better player if he’s played twice and hasn’t won. Dan played once and Won and has a shot to win again.