Best BB Player Bracket: Dr. Will vs. Eric

Who was the better Big Brother player?

Best BB Player Bracket: Dr. Will vs. Eric

Dr. Will Kirby: Big Brother 2

1. Was part of the first true strategic alliance of any Big Brother season, “Chilltown”
2. His strategy was to combine charm with lies. Despite being nominated four times, his strategy worked and Will was winner of Big Brother 2
3. Appeared on Big Brother: All Stars where he finished in fourth place

Eric Stein: Big Brother 8
1. First ever America’s Player, Eric would attempt to complete a series of tasks given to him by poll votes from viewers, where he would be rewarded $10,000 for each task completed

2. Eric is best known for his “showmance” with Jessica Hughbanks
3. Was the 10th player evicted, placing 5th and becoming the 5th member of the jury

Vote for today's female house guests!

Not sure what the Big Brother bracket is about? Learn more about it here.



  • Kungfuwomn

    You would think Will would be winning by a landslide considering alot of BB fans think he’s like the best player of all time! I know i dont even though he won i just dont think if he was playing the show like in the past 6 years or so that he wouldn’t be as good as he was back when BB was new and other players were naive to let him walk all over them.So im glad that Eric is getting alot of votes against Will. I think Janelle is much better then Will.

    • tom

      the only reason will wouldn’t do well now, is because everyone knows how dangerous he is and would rush to vote him out. In AllStars people underestimated him because he was from an early season, and he ran the show. Yes he played a simpler game (BB2 didn’t have vetos even) but he won it because he had the best social game, which is the most important skill.

  • Andrew Sloan

    ROUND 3!! WOOT!! Poll already closed… :O. Well, my vote would go to Will. Eric was a very good strategical player but Will was downright amazing at playing the game and everyone else in it. Since both had a lackluster physical competitive side, social gameplay (which is one of the most important aspects anyways) has to decide my vote. I’ll check back later though.

    • Faceones

      its not closed i just voted

  • Leb123isme

    i loved both eric and will, but will wins every time. every time.

  • pondscum

    who r coming up with these questions?

  • Honestjo

    never did like dr will. I think Janelle is better even though she had never won it.