Reality Nation » Big Brother » Best BB Player Bracket: Erika vs. Dani

Best BB Player Bracket: Erika vs. Dani

Who was the better Big Brother player?

Erika Landin (@erikaBB4): Big Brother 4

1. Part of the Eight Elite & Girl Power Alliance
2. Returned for All Stars
3. Runner up of All Stars where she received only one vote from the jury

Dani Donato (@danidONAT0): Big Brother 8, 13
1. Runner up season 8 & Part of the Veterans alliance season 13
2. 5 POV wins in season 8
3. Her loyalties were: Season 8 Dick Donato, season 13 Dominic Briones, Kalia Booker and
Porsche Briggs

Vote for today’s male house guests!

Not sure what the Big Brother bracket is about? Learn more about it here.

Comments

sepen

Easy! Dani wins this one
- http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa
  
  She will, but she shouldn’t.
  - sepen
    
    No one cares what you think! go away and stop posting.
  - nykia71
    
    Of course Dani should win, don’t like her much, way to arrogant but she is a better player than Erika (JMO) Erika done nothing but ride Boogie to the end literally. Dani way to cocky that’s what I believe cost her the game last season.
  - http://twitter.com/Bad_Ass_McD_Fan Jake Taylor
    
    All that Erika did had a showmance. She wasn’t originally gonna be on All-Stars. They asked back Jun but she denied it, and so they asked back Ericka as a replacement for Jun (though they should of just replaced Jun with Jack and Cowboy with Adria).
    
    Daniele is an excellent competitor and she wasn’t afraid to get blood on her hands. If they didn’t had the twist where somebody returns back into the house for a 2nd/3rd chance, she will probably make it to the end along with Kalia, Lawon, and Porsche since Rachel would of gone home during Kalia’s first HOH, and the only real person that they have to worry about is Jeff since Jordan and Shelly were terrible in competitions and Adam basically has no allegiances.
  - http://twitter.com/Bad_Ass_McD_Fan Jake Taylor
    
    All that Erika did had a showmance. She wasn’t originally gonna be on All-Stars. They asked back Jun but she denied it, and so they asked back Ericka as a replacement for Jun (though they should of just replaced Jun with Jack and Cowboy with Adria).
    
    Daniele is an excellent competitor and she wasn’t afraid to get blood on her hands. If they didn’t had the twist where somebody returns back into the house for a 2nd/3rd chance, she will probably make it to the end along with Kalia, Lawon, and Porsche since Rachel would of gone home during Kalia’s first HOH, and the only real person that they have to worry about is Jeff since Jordan and Shelly were terrible in competitions and Adam basically has no allegiances.
    - http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa
      
      Danielle S8 is a wash since producer/audience intervention completely skewed that season. But Danielle S13 completely played herself right out of the game so early she barely made jury. Not the great player you all make her out to be, though she did make S13 entertaining.
      
      Erika made some mistakes but she knew how to ride out a good thing while she could and not burn her bridges. Even though she got used by Boogie she still used it to reap the benefits after figuring it out. She edges out Danielle IMO.
      - http://twitter.com/Bad_Ass_McD_Fan Jake Taylor
        
        “Danielle S8 is a wash since producer/audience intervention completely skewed that season.”
        
        Same thing can be said with Rachel, Jeff, and Jordan.
        
        If Jeff didn’t had the Coup de Tat in BB11, it would of been Jessie’s alliance to the end, and JeJo wouldn’t even make it far.
        
        As for Rachel, the Pandora’s Box Porsche opened made Jordan and Rachel go to the final 4 Veto together. Take a look at the final 6 Veto competition, and then look at the first HOH. Plus, Rachel would of gone the week Lawon screwed up if Alison Grodner didn’t purposely had that twist where Brendan got back in the game (Which was rigged).
        
        Dani gotten screwed by Grodner in BB13 by having her set up that twist. If Alison were not had that twist, then it would of been her, Kalia, Porsche, and Lawon in the final 4.
      - http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa
        
        Not sure why you went off on a tangent there but I agree about Rachel, Jeff, and Jordan; I don’t consider any of them good players.
        
        And you can assume whatever you like about what would or would not have happened if there hadn’t been any twist, but when you start basing your vote on a hypothetical situation you should take step back and realize you’re not thinking straight. And you’re wrong about that final 4 BTW.
haleyy

vote dani
http://twitter.com/iamcodyallen Official Cody Allen

Easy, Dani got my vote!
http://twitter.com/iamcodyallen Official Cody Allen

Dani would have won season 13 if she would have waited a little bit longer before she turned on the veterans. But she was right in doing that because if she would have been in the final 5 with them she would have been out quick. She needed a partner but JeJo and Brenchal didn’t want to let her have one so she did what she had to do and I respect that. She still did good with her alliance of Kalia and Porsche. Team Dani 100%!
- blackingouthenegativity
  
  People seem to forget that if Brendon wasn’t voted back into the game that Dani & Kalia would have gotten out three veterans in a row.
Browna17

Dani wins this one she did not ride any coatails to get to the end of season 8 she did however use her father as a shield and since people hated him more she knew people would evict him first if they were personal players if they were smart strategic players they would have evicted her. She’s competitive mentally and physically. In BB13 she did well until she turned on the vets too early. If she would have. Waited a few more weeks she would ha have won

Erica on the other hand was an alright player she floated in both seasons winning HOH once a season her downfall was not winning when she needed to she always relied on people bringing her to the end instead of doing it herself and her showmance with boogie sealed her fate as well my vote goes to…dani
http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000175635622 Andrew Sloan

I’ll admit that I though Erika should’ve made it to the end in season 4 and even deserved to (or at least make it to final 3 and beat out Robert). But all-stars was embarrassing to watch. She floated all the way through, and the only reason she was brought so far was because Boogie could easily manipulate her. Granted she is a good physical player, her social game suffered in season 7 because of how emotionally attached she became to Boogie (This can LARGELY be seen when she nominated Danielle in the final 6).
Daniele on the other hand caught a few breaks in season 8 with America’s player, but she tied the record for POV wins in a season with Janelle and she was good at bringing people to her side (S8: Jen, Zach, S13: Kalia, Porsche, Shelly- sort of). Daniele is a great physical and social player and also fun to watch but she had a big downfall in both seasons- Nick in S8 & Dominic in S13.