Best BB Player Bracket: Janelle vs. Alison

Who was the better Big Brother player?

Best BB Player Bracket: Janelle vs. Alison

Janelle Pierzina (@JanellePierzina): Big Brother 6

1. Janelle won every America’s Choice award during Big Brother 6 and appeared on All Stars where she came in 3rd place for the second time
2. Known for her phrase “Bye bye, bitches!” which has become wildly popular in the Big Brother community
3. Is currently tied for the most Power of Veto wins

Alison Irwin: Big Brother 4

1. Won the first ever Diamond Power of Veto in Big Brother History
2. She was the runner-up and won $50,000 in Big Brother 4
3. Alison appeared on Big Brother: All Stars

Vote for today’s male house guests here!

Not sure what the Big Brother bracket is about? Learn more about it here.


  • Andrew Sloan

    Alison played a good overall game in season 4, however all-stars didn’t work out that well, where Janelle actually got her out. Janelle won 4 HOHs in season 7, plus 5 POVS and 2 HOHs and 2 POVs in season 6. That record is friggen awesome. The only bad thing I can point out about Janelle’s game is that Will controlled her way too easily, up until the final 4 that is. Regardless, Janelle placed Final 3 in both seasons and played a great game. My vote goes to Janelle

    • Leb123isme

      Janelle rocks and lets face it, Will controlled everyone easily :)

    • Carol Villabona

      I don’t believe Will controlled Janelle as much as some want to believe. I think, in fact, that Janelle had Will doing her dirty work. She feigned not being able to evict James, so Will went after James instead. Will lost complete track of his game (spending time defending her to Boogie and the others when he should have been trying to get her out of the house) and in the end, he trusted her “200%” as he’d always say, as she lied to his face that he was safe and then she kicked him out. If you ever look at Janelle’s DR’s you’d see that she never, ever stop saying that she wanted Chilltown gone. She tried to get Boogie out first (but dumb Erika didn’t keep her word and vote Boogie out when she promised to) and she finally did get rid of Will. I will always vote for Janelle!

      • Andrew Sloan

        I completely agree with voting for Janelle, but she admitted it in the final veto speech that she made too many mistakes that season. Will got Janelle to nominate Marcellas, ensuring her that Marcellas was safe, but in fact he planned on evicting her. Also in the double eviction Will was right in her face telling her what to do. She eventually saw all of what he was doing and voted him out, over Erica in the final 4 though

        • Carol Villabona

          Actually, Janelle said in chat after Allstars that she WANTED Marcellas out (she knew he was plotting against her) but she let Will be responsible for it so that she could get Marcellas jury vote if she was in final 2 (she said “do you really think I believed Will was crying???”). The double eviction you speak of, Janie wasn’t so concerned with what happened because she was trying to get rid of Boogie. If Erika had not gone back on her word, it would have worked out just as Janelle wanted it to. So happy that Janelle chatted and told us what was going on, people want to think that Will controlled her and nothing could be further from the truth.

  • Faceones

    was not for boogie goofy move in final 3 Janelle would have never let volcano go

  • TweetsRide

    Without Janelle and Will, Miami would be winless today.

  • Official Cody Allen

    Janelle is amazing! Alison only got so far because she used her slutty side as an advantage. Nothing wrong with that..especially since it worked…for the most part at least.