Reality Nation » Big Brother » Best BB Player Bracket: Jordan vs. Rachel

Best BB Player Bracket: Jordan vs. Rachel

Who was the better Big Brother player?

Jordan Lloyd (@BBJordanLloyd): Big Brother 11
1. Winner of BB 11 and appeared again in Season 13
2. Jordan partnered with Jeff Schroeder. Her second duo partner was Rachel Reilly
3. Nominated for eviction BB11 4 times (weeks 2, 3, 8, & 9) Nominated for eviction BB13 3 times (weeks 4, 8 and day 69)

Rachel Reilly (@RachelEReilly): Big Brother 12 & Big Brother 13
1. Winner of BB13
2. Is the third House Guest (and second female) to win the first Head of Household competition and the game following Lisa Donahue and Hayden Moss
3. Part of the Veterans Alliance. Loyal to Brendon Villegas and Jordan Lloyd

Vote for today’s male houseguests!

Not sure what the Big Brother bracket is about? Learn more about it here.

Comments

http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=727416026 Luke Anyanka Bright-Pyle

I dont know if either of them should be here in my books… But I have to give it to Rachel, the competitive gameplay appeals to me a lot more than the floater strategy
Cameronc1996

Go Rachel all the way. She won a lot of competitions and actually played the game:) You all have to vote for her.
- gma
  
  HAVE TOO? Really? Again, being a good player is how you look at it. Winning competitions does not necessarily make you the better player. Jordan had the best social game, Rachel had NO social game. Rachel had the better competitive game. To me, BB is more about the social game than the competitive game. It is much easier to win comps and be HOH, safe from elimination, and POV’s, making you safe from elimination that it is to be eligible for nomination, nominated and still stay in the game. To me, Jordan played the better game. My opinion.
  - Kalimnafisi
    
    First off, you are entitled to your own opinion so I will give you that. But Jordan did not have the best social game in either of her seasons. In bb11 she won because Jessie and Lydia got mad over natalies age, for no reason. In bb12, not many people liked her either. Her social was better then Rachel, but definately not the best.
    - guest1
      
      oh im sorry were jessie and lydia the only ones voting in bb11..huh guess i will have to go back and watch that i must have missed something.and btw bb rocket scientist jordan wasnt on bb12
      - Corndogger
        
        Flip those two votes and Scrappy would have won 4-3 over Jordan. I’ve said this before and I’ll say it again, Michele did Jordan a huge favor by getting those two to flip their votes.
      - guest1
        
        okay…who told u that michelle got them to flip their votes? they have a mind ..lydia hated natalie anyway so she wasnt going to vote for her. jordan would have won regardless she had americas vote,jeff,michelle and lydia.. Scrappy do wasnt going to win shit
      - Faceones
        
        michelle noonan ok now i know your off deep end
Billyw

Jordan wasn’t a FLOATER!.. people need to learn the definition of a floater, a floater is one who flip flops between alliances. Jordan was horrible at competitions but she WAS NOT a floater, she stayed true to her alliance
- http://twitter.com/therocprince Cory
  
  Your right, Jordan was a piggy-backer not a floater.
  - AnnieO
    
    but she managed to kick butt at her final competitions when she won.
    - Kalimnafisi
      
      How the heck did she Kick Butt? She dropped first in part 1, then won part 2 and 3. That is not Kicking butt
      - guest1
        
        umm okay your logic makes no sense ..she lost one round but she one the final three rounds? huh im scratching my head what more does she have to do? she kicked ass for sure in the finals that season no question about it.
      - tgrfan42069
        
        2 of 3 is kicking butt
haleyy

omg i cant believe you guys think that jordan is the best competitor of ALL THE GIRLS OF BB that is just ridiculous!!! it’s all favoritism with the stupid annoying jeff and jordan fans like your suppose to vote for the better players and jordan did absolutely nothing on both seasons so, this was just a waste of superpasses time because obvioulsey jordan was gunna win. and jordan over RACHEL rachel, daniele, and janele were by far the best players of BB so jeff and jordan fans you are being unfair! so vote for the better player not! who you like better jordan was a complete floater.And obviousley the jeff and jordan fas will disagree becasue they’re just annoying go back to your little fansite and go play on that cause noone wants you here
- guest1
  
  waaaah!!! cry me a river you loser..jeff and jordan fans have just as much right as you do to be here..and its all opinion who you think deserves it more and who in the hell are you to make that judgement call for anyone.and by the way i am a fan of more then jeff and jordan but i can appreciate an awesome fan base and that “little fansite” that you are obviously jealous of is kicking the shit out of these polls so why dont you go back to playing with your barbie dolls and leave the grown up stuff to everyone else.
  - Faceones
    
    hey i am jejo fan and i agree rachel should win guest 1 whoever u are yes i am rachel reilly fan
    - guest1
      
      i like rachel.its just all a matter of opinion whoever wins this poll its not going to change the world we are not voting for president
- AnnieO
  
  everyone who wins BB got there on the backs of others. it’s the nature of the game. without alliances you get booted out pretty quick. the fact J/J became a couple has nothing to do with it. after 13 seasons if you haven’t figured out that this is mostly a popularity contest you should just stop watching.
  - twentyfivemanroster
    
    Not necessarily true. I would argue that Rachel HAD to do it herself. She played a great game, won when she had to. I think her personality is what won it for her. Porsche didn’t think Rachel would win because of her cattiness, but great game play FINALLY win out.
- AnnieO
  
  the whole poll was wacky, it was just a bit of fun, don’t get your knickers in a knot.
Jwoods440

people, this is the best player not your favorite player, rachel played a much superior game to jordan, vote for rachel
- guest1
  
  i really like rachel but i do not believe for one second that rachel would have had a shot at winning bb13 if it was not for jeff and jordan especially jordan..they fought for her and had her back the whole way. Give credit where it is due..its all a matter of opinion
  - http://twitter.com/SnideSnidington SnideSnidington
    
    It is not an opinion to think that Jordan is the best female PLAYER in Big Brother history, it is simply idiocy.
    - guest1
      
      again thats your opinon…it will be okay take your ativan and calm down
      - Faceones
        
        again who r u?
  - Corndogger
    
    Nice revisionist history. Those three were trying to get rid of each other for the first third of the game. The person who truly had Rachel’s back the entire time (other than Brendon) was Porsche.
    - guest1
      
      porsche? now that really is a joke…when would she have had rachel’s back in between sleeping all the time and then stuffing her face..now thats a good one cornhole..i mean corndogger
      - Doodoodoowgas
        
        I don’t like you.
      - guest1
        
        and i give a shit why? i wont lose any sleep..what you dont like is the fact that the person you vote for is not winning…BFD…grow up and stop acting 2
      - Faceones
        
        finally i agree with something u said
  - Faceones
    
    my opinion u should at least tell u who u are
    - guest1
      
      and who r u again? oh thats right your i dont give a shit who you are ..have a nice day
- tgrfan42069
  
  i wouldnt say that.rach made the whole house mad at her.i wouldnt call that superior game play
Coloradoangel1978

this one was hard for me. They both played the game the best they could. Jordan lacked comp skills and Rachel lacked social skills. I did throw my vote to Jordan because I like her better. Yes, I picked the one I liked better personally because I think they both played the game equally and both won the game. That was the only way could break the tie.
http://twitter.com/therocprince Cory

*clears throat*, are these my only choices…can we have an option for “Other”?
Kalimnafisi

The problem with these votes is no one votes based off of Gameplay, but likeability. Jordan may be a nice girl, but She didnt do anything in big brother 11, and lost because of a Bitter jury, solely cause Natalie made a lie about age. Lydia and Jessie were useless anyway, so Jordan pretty much won cause of bitterness. Then in big brother 13, she didnt do anything. And then she admitted that Rachel was a better at Big brother. Rachel worked her ass off to win Big brother 13 with so many competition wins. When you see Jordan beating out people like Janelle and Danielle Reyes, you know that they are not voting on Gameplay
http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000175635622 Andrew Sloan

There is really no use in commenting on these anymore. Janelle should be here, not Jordan. So if Jordan is the best female player then Robyn Kass and Allison Grodner should just throw a bunch of Jordans in the house. Who wants to see that? Maybe a bunch of Rachels, Janelles or Danieles. But not Jordans.
- Kalimnafisi
  
  This Is A Great comment! Cause Its true, but Im hoping you are talking about Danielle Reyes. Heck I would be fine with both
  - http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000175635622 Andrew Sloan
    
    YA! Both Danielle Reyes and Daniele Donato make good BB TV. A Bunch of Jordans would not
    - guest
      
      I would rather watch Jordan than those two any day
Elizabeth

I thoroughly enjoy Rachel’s competitive ability. It was fun to see Rachel and Jordan paired up last year. They complimented each other so well. I believe Jordan had a spot on social game both seasons and has tremendous instincts as it pertains to reading people. So a tough call, but going to Jordan this round.
TheRealDeal

The funniest part of this contest is all this bickering amongst fans . Jeff and Jordan are oblivious to this contest and haven’t tweeted or spoken 1 word about it , lmao . Infact I don’t think ANY of the hg’s have , oh , except for Jun and Michele N. , and they are just sad and desperate to remain relevant. How can some ppl be so pissed that Jeff and Jordan have so many fan’s , I mean seriously , aren’t there better thing’s going on in the world today to waste your anger on , how about on , i dunno , maybe the dreadful state of our economy for one. Just my thought’s.
- Dan
  
  You know what I really think….They followed some of the other HGs example…Jordan winning and being loved as much as she is ..stuck in peoples craws,Couldnt be so,shes tooo stupid and she got the guy they think they could of fucked at Vegas bash.
http://twitter.com/DivrDown41 Jim

The process was just named incorrectly. Should have been “Favorite” BB player. I am avid JeJo fan. But I did vote for Rachel, since I am an avid fan of hers as well. And I did vote for Dan.
chellelynn2

We all have our favorite BB houseguests.. we all argue who was better .. guess that just shows how much passion us fans have for BB. Can’t wait for another season!! lol
Ashley F

I love Jeff/Jordan but they are not the best players. They were never true to an alliance, Rachel is the one that kept Jordan in the BB house longer, ughh so stupid. This poll is ridiculous!
- Dan
  
  Delusional..(about keeping in the game)
  - Faceones
    
    what feed did u watch?
Mat

OK now i’m mad! Jordan was not as good as all of these girls! Sorry cat ladies!!!
kungfuwomn

This is really a joke i want to know why under Rachel’s description they dont list all her HOH and POV wins she has and that like Janelle was hated and still won comps and that she is ranked on the top of winning the most comps with Janelle so people can see a fair comparison.I thought Janelle should have won over Jodan but at least alot of the younger people probably never saw Janelle play but Jordan was on same season with Rachel and people could see who was the stronger competetor.So obviously this is just who is the most popular contest and now who is actually the better Big Brother player because I love Jordan and JEJO i really do but Janelle and Rachel are better Big Brother Players then Jordan.
133355

Will the world explode if Jeff and Jordan go against each other in the brackets??
Barbara Brown

Out of these two, I would pick Jordan, but no means is she the best player ever. Are you kidding me …. Janelle would swallow these two up and spit them out. Everyone has their own place and both Jordan and Rachel have won, Janelle has not. Don’t get me wrong, huge BB fan and Rachel and Jordan sure are entertaining, but if you appreciate the BB house as a game…Rachel and Jordan are not either in the top two. No way
Kyraben

Lol at everyone complaining about the Jejo fans ruining the vote. If you think someone else was a better competitor, then get their fans together and vote for them. That’s the point of an online poll. The fans vote.
http://www.facebook.com/people/Tom-Palmer/898110719 Tom Palmer

well, i hate that jeff and jordan made it this far. and i’m hoping against hope that dan wins. but jordan is a better player than rachel because she actually has a social game.
kungfuwomn

I beg to differ Rachel played a better game,Rachel played a social game in BB13 but Dani and Shelly turned everything upside down with their gameplay of hate and game calling whether it was game or not.You have to have more then a social game to win BB you have to win comps and when it came to physical comps Jordan was horrible? I still love her but Rachel carried her in the last half of the game winning the comps and keeping her in game.So overall Rachel is the better player.
- guest
  
  OMG for the millionth time BB is not a game of who wins the most competitions, that’s called the Olympics. BB is a social game and the idea is to not get voted out and nobody in the history of BB has done it better than Jordan except Dr Will and they are tied.
  - Corndogger
    
    But Jordan had the producers helping her and Dr. Will did not.
    - Dan
      
      So did Evel..What does that tell you.
      - Faceones
        
        ya evel only won because of nutty voting on america player
  - Dan
    
    I believe Dr.Will proved that in season 2.It was Janie who started the whole competitor crap.and look where that got her………Twice!!
- Dan
  
  Dani and Shelly Did fuck Rachels game (for awhile ,mind you it was mostly Dani),even trying to get Brendon against her,thinking he”d go against his GF (they’re nuts but not that nuts) and side with her(,thought she was the shit she did.)But it was Jordan that kept Rachel in the game the First half(Jordan had enough of the nasty comments towards Rachel from the other girls and knew it wasn’t All Rachel like everyone was saying she was..It was Jordan that calmed Rachel down enough to focus on her game.
  - Faceones
    
    that has nothing to do with best player u voted for jordan just for popularity that is just nuts
honestjo

LOL! my vote of course was or Rachel. This is a popularity contest when Jordan, who I do love dearly, she is a sweetheart and yes I got the live feeds. People can have their moments and shelly deserved it lol. Anyway this is about the better player and Janelle first got kicked our because off jordan, um oh PLEASEEEEE. Now she is going to kick Rachel out too. LOL the two players who I thought were the best jordan is kicking out. Oh well it is just a game. Its just funny
http://www.facebook.com/queenkirby Laura Skelton Kirby

Rachel was the best physical player of all the women, but Jordan was the best @ flying under the radar.
Kingsgrl2010

I CAN’T PICK BETWEEN JORCHEL!!!
Paula

Wow polls still open at 3:00 am?
Bbfan13

Wow 4 am and polls still open, I guess they’ll stay open until RN/SP get the winner they want.
Pbuc376202

rachel all the way.
Royrescue

Jordan deserves the votes! I want to know how Lidia and Chima gets 66 and 64 votes each?
- Faceones
  
  for best player no for most popular yes what is this called best player will should have won anyway jeff best player not
VikingsGrl2004

OBVIOUSLY this should have been “Who is your FAVORITE PLAYER” instead of who’s the best ~ I LOVE JORDAN but she WAS NOT THE BEST PLAYER ~ just sayin
Angel Heart

Rachel all the way!!!!!!!! Jordan did hardly anything.
RREe

Are these damn polls open for a damn day? What the hell is wrong with everyone voting for Jordan?
kungfuwomn

RN doesnt care who wins if so the poll would have been named most popular BB players,this is just something to do until BB starts basically its just a popularity contest.I am so not taking this poll serious as the who are the best Female and Male BB Players of all time and i think the majority of the people voting and the BB players themselves are not taking this seriously.Just get heated sometimes but basically its just a way to spend the time until BBstarts and to have people talking.You notice the BB players except maybe one or two have even commented on the polls cuz they know its just for a good laugh.
honestjo

you have got to be kidding!! LOL! ok now we know it is going to be jordan and jeff. It should of been down to janelle and rachel for the winner if people would of picked for who played the game the best not who you liked the best. I really like Jordan but the people who vote for her should come out and say the truth you voted because you love her not because she played the best game. Rachel won and she totally deserved the win. There is no way Jordan deserves the win. she didn’t win the comps like rachel and janelle did. Both faught hard because everyone wanted them out and they had to keep winning. I am not mad though its only a game lol. I don’t know who deserved to win janelle or rachel. janelle never one bb but I don’t know. I think Janelle has a bigger fan base and would of won
- Rickjohnson75
  
  You meant “should have” or “should’ve.” There is no such thing as “should of.” Please write this down on a sticky note and stick it to your computer monitor. Also, please tell everyone you know. Thanks!
- Rickjohnson75
  
  Also, you meant “would have” or “would’ve.” There is no such thing as “would of.” Please write this down on a sticky note and stick it to your computer monitor. Also, please tell everyone you know. Thanks!
  - honestjo
    
    do you like to be nasty? just asking. I wasn’t being nasty. Excuse me for saying things the incorrect way for you and I don’t know everything never said I did. I am sorry for saying I think people voted for jordan because they love her not how she played the game. It is just an opionion, just like yours and both are opinions can be wrong. I do not dislike Jordan actually think she is great. So if I upset anyone I am sorry
Meg

Poll doesn’t say best competitor. BB is more than competions. Dr. Will didn’t win one & yet he is revered as the best BB player ever. It takes so much more than just winning comps. Its comps, social & a whole lot of luck.
http://twitter.com/Bronx_babygirl omayra fontanez

Jordan ALL THE WAY!!!! I cant stand that nasty witch Rachel
Icureec52

I want the show to put new people in there. Hate the ones that they keep bring back . Hey you had your chance let some of the rest of the world get a chance at the money. This goes for all reality shows. Rachel has cried the money river to long. BB and then Amazing Race. Then all the times they have been on Bold and the Beautiful. Don’t you have enough already?????
Guest

Really? Jordan did nothing except complain that Porsche did nothing
ujdbufvbufbvufb

Jordan is one of the absolute weakest players to ever win this game. If you don’t think so you’re a biased moron. Janelle is hands down the best of the girls EVER
ujdbufvbufbvufb

Jordan is one of the absolute weakest players to ever win this game. If you don’t think so you’re a biased moron. Janelle is hands down the best of the girls EVER