Best BB Player Bracket: Michelle C. vs. Erika

Who was the better Big Brother player?

Best BB Player Bracket: Michelle C. vs. Erika

Michelle Costa (MichelleBB10): Big Brother 10

1. Was the seventh House Guest evicted from the season during a Fast Forward Week
2. Placed 7th and became the third member of the jury
3. Known in the community as the Portuguese Princess of Providence

Erika Landin (@erikaBB4): Big Brother 4
1. Part of the Eight Elite & Girl Power Alliance
2. Returned for All Stars
3. Runner up of All Stars where she received only one vote from the jury

Vote for today’s male house guests here!

Not sure what the Big Brother bracket is about? Learn more about it here.

Comments

  • Kungfuwomn

    Who won the most comps between the two i think it was Michelle so i voted for her.

    • http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa

      What a stupid way to vote.

      • Corndogger

        If winning comps was so important then Dr. Will would be ranked as one of the worst players ever not best. I’m starting to wonder if a lot of BB viewers even understand how the game works.

        • Chelsiea

          blah! There are thousands and thousands of bb fans who don’t consider dr. will as one of the best players. And Yes, we understand how the game works. Your opinion of how the game works is just that, YOUR opinion so shut up and step away from the podium already!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=727416026 Luke Anyanka Bright-Pyle

    If Jen had made it to this position, I would find it a hard choice, but Michelle played the game better IMO, I dont like Erikas gameplay tbh.

    • http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa

      She played it better and yet left far earlier than Erika did in either of her seasons?

      I feel like you people use a bunch of stock lines to justify voting for somebody you like better even though it doesn’t make any sense.

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=727416026 Luke Anyanka Bright-Pyle

        Don’t deindividualize my opinion. This is an opinion poll, I vote on who I thought played the better game. How I come to decide that is up to me and I think a more aggressive game is a better game.

        Just because you think a certain way, and certain things make sense in your mind. Doesn’t make it fact.

        • http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa

          Here are some facts for you my friend:

          Erika Landin
          Season 4: Fourth Place, Nominated 3 Times
          Season 7: Second Place, Nominated 4 Times

          Michelle Costa
          Season 10: Seventh Place, Nominated 1 Time

          The numbers don’t lie. Not only did Erika place better both times she played, she was also able to survive nomination multiple times by playing people strategically and keeping her composure. Michelle did none of those things, and your belief that “aggressive gameplay is better” has no grounding in reality.

          Of course you can have your opinion, but your opinion can be wrong.

          • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000175635622 Andrew Sloan

            You can never go by the facts. You have to watch the seasons and know the game. A floater can make it far into the game (as erika did in season 7) but that doesn’t make them a better player. You can’t sit here and say Erika is a better player then Janelle because Erika got 2nd and Janelle got 3rd. And Erika was hardly ever a target. She was nominated so many times because the HOH thought the person they nominated against her would go home because she was such a bad player.

          • http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa

            Actually I could make that argument, not that I personally agree with it, but it could definitely be made. I’m not suggesting you take a person’s rank in the house alone as the only measure of their gameplay, but it’s definitely a good place to start. Erika survived nominations as a pawn on a show where “the pawn always goes home”, that’s no coincidence. She had a great way of getting in with both the guys and the girls, and yet staying under the radar enough to avoid eviction week after week. You say she was hardly ever a target like it’s a bad thing.

            On the flip side, Michelle had no real close relationships in the house except with Jessie (who was a nonsensical choice to get attached to) and she let her emotions get the best of her throughout the whole season (e.g. getting involved in fights, picking her nominations based on revenge, etc). There was not one redeeming quality about her gameplay other than perhaps her awareness of who was deceiving who in the house.

            You’re simply wrong about this my friend.

          • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=727416026 Luke Anyanka Bright-Pyle

            I feel its useless replying, but a persons opinion cant be wrong, its the whole point of having an opinion.

          • http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa

            Wrong again.

          • Dan

            Hypocrite.

          • http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa

            Ignorant.

  • http://www.facebook.com/mzeigler Melissa Zeigler

    I must vote for Michelle today! IMO she played a better game.

    • http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa

      lol.

  • http://www.facebook.com/scott.james.129 Scott James

    My vote goes to Michelle

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000175635622 Andrew Sloan

    Erika played a good game in season 4, but that is often overlooked because of her trash strategy and getting played by Boogie in season 7. Michelle was awesome and although not the best player, i think she outplayed Erika

    • http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa

      LMAO are you guys getting something under the table?

      Hey Michelle! Drop me some dough over PayPal and I’ll lie about what a good player you were too! Hit me up to twitter baby girl!

      • Corndogger

        I love your posts. One of the few people who are voting based on the stated criteria.

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000175635622 Andrew Sloan

        I just didn’t vote for Erika because she was soooo bad in season 7, it was embarrassing for me to watch. She did good in season 4, although only winning 1 competition that season. I just voted for Michelle because she was a good physical competitor and she never got played by anyone. She was always aware of what was going on.
        It’s all opinion, but I’ve been voting for who I think the best player is. I did not want to vote for Boogie today, but did because he is a better player.
        But I’ll gladly take some money for Michelle :D

        • http://twitter.com/EhJayAych DaBa

          See reply below. By the way, you say Michelle was a great physical competitor, yet she only won one veto and one HoH. Versus Erik’s 2 vetos and one HoH in S7. I don’t think skill in competitions means shit in rankings, but if you’re going to use it then at least do your research.

          • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000175635622 Andrew Sloan

            I don’t have to do research. I’ve watched season 10 two and a half times and all stars at least 3 times (I’ve only seen season 4 once though- but i’ve seen the best of a few times). But i see where you’re coming from. Plus erika already won so there is no point arguing about this. I still think Michelle is better, but that’s just my opinion