Reality Nation » Big Brother » Best BB Player Bracket: Rachel vs. Dani

Best BB Player Bracket: Rachel vs. Dani

Who was the better Big Brother player?

Rachel Reilly (@RachelEReilly): Big Brother 12 & Big Brother 13

1. Winner of BB13.

2. Is the third House Guest (and second female) to win the first Head of Household competition and the game following Lisa Donahue and Hayden Moss.

3. Part of the Veterans Alliance. Loyal to Brendon Villegas and Jordan Lloyd.

Dani Donato (@danidONAT0): Big Brother 8, 13

1. Runner up season 8 & Part of the Veterans alliance season 13

2. 5 POV wins in season 8

3. Her loyalties were: Season 8 Dick Donato, season 13 Dominic Briones, Kalia Booker and Porsche Briggs

Vote for today’s male houseguests!

Not sure what the Big Brother bracket is about? Learn more about it here.

Comments

kungfuwomn

I think whoever writes the info about the players needs to change them before the finals.I think how many HOH’s and POV’s Rachel won in both seasons needs to be added plus the fact that she was a target and hated like Janelle was and still won.Considering we know who the final 2 woman will be and i think people should know all of Rachel’s accomplishments even though im afraid she will lose out in this popularity contest!
- Dan
  
  Oh go cry in the bushes will ya.
  - Faceones
    
    u just mad she won
    - Dan
      
      No I like Rachel it’s karate I’m not into
- Manley
  
  Oh, good lord, please don’t compare that desperate, needy shrew to Janelle, she doesn’t hold a candle to her. Confident, secure Janelle was actually FEARED by her fellow hgs, so much so that even before Allstars started, they were calling each other, plotting how to get her out of the house! Rachel was hated because she was whiny, crazy, uppity and nasty to people (remember the whole “Ragan, do you want some gooey cookies?” when she knew the guy was on slop?). Rachel won her season ONLY because of the twists, turns and Pandoras boxes that Grodner threw in to help her and Jordan, and that is the only reason.
  - BB1113
    
    Not thee biggest Rachel fan, but none of the twists would have mattered if Rachel hadnt kept winning. Just ask Jordan.
    - BBForever
      
      Well when the producers repeat the same competition that she ALREADY won, it’s no wonder she is going to continue to win. That’s common sense.
http://twitter.com/muddythecat Chris Kelly

Rachel is consistently Rachel, I really like Dani’s game but she seems a little inconsistent.
http://twitter.com/TonyVolpe78 Volpe

it pains me to vote for Rachel
Harrybirm

No contest imo.Dant played her game on her own,Rach had Brennan,Jeff and Jordan along with the floater of the week.I think Dani played the best game./
David Mager

Daniele is a better phhysically,strategically, and socially. The only reason Rachel won is because of the twists that favored her and if Brendon didnt come back dani would of won the game. Also Daniele should of won bb8 she was the strategy behind the donato duo.
- Faceones
  
  not dani would have won she stayed with her vet alliance
http://twitter.com/bronsonsherrie sherriebronson

Rachel plotted against her alliance with Jeff and Jordan behind Brenden’s back to Dani and Porche, plotted against Brendon to keep Dom with Dani, plotted against her alliance with Jordan near the end of game to Porche so was never loyal on strategy with her partners but did win competition and play both sides and got to the final 2 where she finally did remain true to her alliance Porche at the time. Nothing but winning matters as she has demonstrated many times and she did win.
- artharsh
  
  Seriously Rachel did not deserve to win the producers kept pushing her sorry ass forward.
David Mager

Lets compare there first time on the show Dani on bb8 dominated in comps. (2 HOH’s and 5 POV’s) and she was the strategy behind the duo she came up with every plan and came in nd place (should have won the game). Rachel only won 2 HOH’s and everyone hated her on her season finished in 9th place. And on bb13 Rachel won 4 HOH’s 2 of them were thrown to her by Dani and Brendon and 2 POV’s 1 was a duo POV and the 2nd one was identical to the 1st HOH and only won because all the twist went her way and when rachel wasnt HOH she just floated. Dani won 2 HOH’s and only competed in 3 HOH’s and the one she lost she gave it to Rachel and Dani would of gone way farther if nobody came back. So head to head i pick Dani (better socially, physically, and strategically)
- Faceones
  
  we never got to see dani and rachel in a endurance so u really cant say that
http://www.facebook.com/people/Tom-Palmer/898110719 Tom Palmer

for those basing their vote on comps, dani won more over both seasons. 9 (4 HoHs and 5 Vetos) while Rachel won 8. (6 HoHs and 2 Vetos)
- Honestjo
  
  very close but you have to put in rachel won and dani didn’t
- Faceones
  
  go back and look again
  - Faceones
    
    she also played in like 6 more comps to
AnnieO

the 2nd time around Dani just didn’t seem to really care about the game.
- http://www.facebook.com/people/Tom-Palmer/898110719 Tom Palmer
  
  Yes she did. On the live feeds she spent hours and hours plotting.
  - Dan
    
    On the feeds she spent hours and hours lying around with Dom and when not doing that was playing pajama bama or what ever thats called
    - David Mager
      
      the pajama jam was at like 4 in the mourning and then the rest of the day she was plotting. Dani gets my vote
      - BB1113
        
        I thought she slept a lot? I am thinking of someone else? I know that they all did though.
      - David Mager
        
        everyone took a lot of naps during the day. the only person that didnt take naps was shelly
      - dwalker
        
        she was trying to keep her lies straight lol
    - TheRealDeal
      
      That’s true. Her drooling allover Dom reminded me of season 8 with Nick , Dani is a comp beast but she isolated herself both seasons for a schoolgirl crush. Rachel was no slouch in the comp’s either ,although she was annoying as hell, so this is a tough choice for some I guess.
http://twitter.com/iamcodyallen Official Cody Allen

Dani is definitely one of my favorite houseguests ever! But if Rachel does win I’ll understand and accept it because Rach is a great player.
http://twitter.com/DTA2K12 Paco G

This is a hard one, Logic says Rachel should win, just because she has won Big Brother and like/hate her she was entertaining.

In BB13 Dani “screwed the pouch” and it’s all cause of her dad leaving and getting gold key so early. But if i forget about BB13 and compare their 1st seasons, Dani is a much better all around player, She is one of the main reasons her Dick won their season.

Had Dick not left last season, it would have been a completely different game for her
- David Mager
  
  Agree you can’t just think of last season. In there first season Dani was great and should of won.
BB1113

Someone said something about Dani being better strategically. I would have to say that her poor strategy in the very beginning cost her the entire game to mention Dom’s.
- David Mager
  
  In bb8 she was amazing strategically and in bb13 she was ok she just made that move a little to early. But she is better than rachel
  - dwalker
    
    in bb8 she rode her dads coat tails.
    - BBForever
      
      That’s bull and you know it. She was the reason that the two of them made it so far. If it weren’t for her 5 POV WINS, or her relationship with ZACH, they would have been out early. DICK didn’t do anything for her except save her that one week. If you actually watched the season, everyone wanted HER out anyway; they didn’t think of Dick as a threat. Besides, Dick’s atrocious social game ultimately rendered him useless.
BB1113

On a side note, why did they have to use that old pic of Dani? She looks like she is starving.
Honestjo

rachel all the way on this one. Dani came in second to give one reason in the one year. rachel won everyone said that is a big deal and I am a feed watcher. if you watch the feeds you can tell the show made rachel look worse then she is and made dani look not as bad in my opinion. Thats beside the point though. I think Rachel earned it, she won it. Dani never did. They both won a lot of contests.
Faceones

guess who won case closed
- David Mager
  
  so you think jordan is one of the 13 best players ever?
  - Faceones
    
    yes she played great social game got real far in her second time to they was so scared of her they voted her off before rachel
David Mager

i feel like people are only thinking of bb13 not bb12 and bb8
http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000175635622 Andrew Sloan

There are pros and cons to both which makes this decision so hard. People praise Dani (which she deserves for the most part), but forget about how her emotional gameplay was pretty bad with Nick and Dominic in the picture. Also Dick helped her a lot in season 8, but she deserved final 2 with all the damage control she had to do (plus all the competitions she won). Rachel causes drama, and without Brendon I very much enjoy and respect her gameplay. With Brendon she becomes supper catty because of the support he offers her. Rachel is also an awesome physical competitor and deserved the win in season 13. This is a tough vote!!!!!!
- David Mager
  
  Daniele is a better competitor than rachel and rachel is the most emotional player ever also dani should of won bb8 she was the strategy behiind the duo (they didnt show that on the show but if you watch the feeds she was)
haleyy

ommggg what is wrong with you peoplee RACHEL REALLY! GO DANI VOTE DANI
Billyw

daniele played sloppy in season 13 and only made it to the final 2 in season 8 because of eric (americas player) if it wasnt for america picking dick to stay over dustin, the season would have been WAYYYYYY different.. the donato’s always make it seem like they were master strategist’s but it was 75% eric doing all the dirty work
- David Mager
  
  but that was the twist from day 1 and the duo twist ended week 3 then came back in the final 6 to save Rachel and Jordan. And Daniele was the best strategist on season 8 by far and on bb13 Daniele’s strategy was a little sloppy but she was the only one strategizing.
dwalker

You go Rachel you earned it.
Kalimnafisi

Dont base your vote off of Twists that helped people. Cause Both had them. America’s choice Saved Dick when his fate was sealed. Without that, danielle would have been eliminated within 1-3 evictions. As for Rachel, the Duo twist and final 6 made no difference. She still would have won veto, jordan evicted, then she would have won HOH Kalia goes home. Porsche evicts Shelly the next week. Both Great players, but Rachel improved alot from her original season, Danielle was not very good without Dick
- blackingouthenegativity
  
  Incorrect.. Even if Rachel did win the veto, Jordan goes home and then Rachel has to force herself to align with Porsche and Kalia.. If Shelly didn’t go home the week before, Rachel might send Shelly home next.